- Written by
spencer096
- Posted July 28, 2009 at 3:00 pm

The guard position in the NFL is, at once, one of the NFL’s most puzzling, diverse and least significant positions…unless you’re blessed with an elite player, which turns the position from being a turnstile for replacement level players to an area of strength. Guards are puzzling in the sense that they are asked to have the strength to deal with king sized DT’s and the speed to handle LB’s at the second level while getting downfield. They’re diverse because every system’s blocking schemes ask for different responsibilities. And least significant because, let’s face it, tackles do the important stuff and are the most physically gifted players along the line while the centers deal with blocking assignments and making sure the line plays as one.
But then you see players like Alan Faneca in the early/mid-2000’s literally carry their offense, and arguably one of the best guards EVER in Steve Hutchinson make the Vikings’ OL a unit to be reckoned with even if the other four members of the line have serious defiencies.
The NFL has shifted it’s areas of importance. No longer is the game played mostly between the tackles, instead becoming wider and wider, hence the importance of a tackle who can protect a QB’s blind side from the ever widening angles of attack pass rusher take. Does this mean the guard is useless? Far from it…because, while running has also shifted outwards, so too has the responsibility of the guard when it comes to pulling.
I’m not going to bore you with OL lingo about technique and scheme responsibility, because really, a guard is simply supposed to knock the fuck out of somebody in order for a hole to open up, so lets get to the list. Actually…lets get to the guys who missed the cut first.
- Brian Waters, KC: Was once the prototypical guard (and is a North Texas alum…ahem) who has been slowed by age recently. Waters’ technique remains flawless, but his physical ability is on the decline.
- Logan Mankins, NE: One of the top 10 interior linemen in the NFL, he’s not on the list because NE doesn’t ask the guards to move as much as a lot of other schemes do.
- Aaron Sears, TB: Very underrated guard, but not on the list just because of the guys who are on it.
- Leonard Davis, Dallas: A bust at tackle, Davis’ athleticism and sheer size makes him an excellent pulling guard. He was miscast as a tackle, but has definitely found his niche as a guard.
- Robert Gallery, Oakland: Laugh if you will, but his technique and speed makes him a capable guard. He wasn’t a good tackle because he has short arms and lacks lateral quickness, but as a guard, his straight-line speed and technique make him effective.
Now to the top 5.
Read the rest of this entry »