But I can’t stop myself.
I don’t know why I was reading The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette* but they ran an article this weekend talking about how the Pirates defense next year might not be as good as it was last year because they got rid of Jack Wilson and Adam LaRoche, etc. He even opens with this:
If the optimistic view about the 2010 Pirates is that there is nowhere to go but up, then this also should be noted: There is nowhere for their defense to go but down.
Unless it finishes No. 1 again.
That was the Pirates’ ranking among all of Major League Baseball last season, despite 99 losses, despite midseason trades of some of their best gloves. The .988 fielding percentage was the best, and the total of 73 errors the lowest.
It’s always funny to see an advocate for a team that lost 99 games last year brag about an aspect of their team. It’s even funnier when they’re not even correct.
- Of the defensive metrics that consider range, put outs, assists, etc: The Pirates had the 7th best defense in baseball (Mariners and Rays were 1st and 2nd).
- Of the 30 baseball teams, fewer than half of them had fielding percentages below .985, which is only 3 points lower than the Pirates
- Of the 30 baseball teams, 5 had between 73 and 78 errors. The worst team in the league had 143.
- The Arizona Diamondbacks committed 124 errors last year. They were the 10th best defensive squad in all of baseball.
The point? Even when the Pirates receive praise it’s done poorly.
Listen, I know Pittsburgh isn’t really a baseball town anymore because their teams sucks so bad and hasn’t been even sorta good since 1992 when they won their last division but that doesn’t excuse their sports writers from still not realizing that fielding percentage should not be anybody’s primary metric for determining how good a team is at defense. Nor should errors be the second. What these two things show is that, of the balls that were hit into play that a Pittsburgh player was able to get to, they made few errors in the act of fielding them.
Consider the Blue Jays and Twins who each had 76 errors, tying them for second in all of baseball–FPs of .987 and .988. These teams are two of the worst defensive squads in the league. The fact they committed so few errors means only that they weren’t fast enough to get to the balls they would have misplayed. Just imagine, if they were slightly quicker, they could have committed dozens more errors!
Its a goddamn wonder why Derek Jeter has so many Gold Gloves.
*Yes I do. It’s because Roman sent me a link to something about Bryce Harper which I couldn’t care less about. There are two types of people in the world: those who get really excited about the MLB draft and those who realize that 99% of draft picks are never going to see a big league game from field level. I fall into the latter category.