- Written by
Major League Jerk
- Posted May 8, 2008 at 9:40 pm
Wally Pipp (n): 1920s Yankees First Basemen who takes a day off and loses starting job to Lou Gherig. wally pipp (v): To have your regular spot in the lineup given over to another player. “I just got wally pipped because Hef’s so talented. Fuck. What am I gonna tell my wife?” Transitive form of verb: to permanently take over an everyday player’s spot. Eric Byrnes, to Jeff Salazer on April 24th after Salazar hit a 2 run homer while filling in for Byrnes who is out with “sore legs” (paraphrase), “Don’t think you’re gonna wally pipp my ass.”
Ah, the fear of being replaced. Ingrained in every big leaguer from the day they eventually replace someone else. This is capitalism at its purist. You’re not cutting it, we’ll replace you with someone who can. You get sick or go on maternity leave because you value family and health? We’ll find some college kid, or worse, a picket line crossing temp to take over for you. Yes, I’ve wondered way past the point, so I’ll steer myself back slowly: at what point is it not okay to replace a player? It’s becoming a big deal here in PHX as Chad Tracy began his minor league rehab stint down in Tucson.
Tracy, as some of you may recall, has been out for the last year with a knee injury. Before he left, he was nice left handed hitter on a young team. In his two complete seasons from 2005-2006, he hit .294 with 47 HRs and 152 RBI on a team that wasn’t producing very many runs. He was a sieve at 3B, leading all National League third basemen in errors but was a steady line drive hitter from the left side of the plate. The reason many of you haven’t heard of him? He was replaced by Mark Reynolds who has much more power and a far better glove. Tracy’s reemergence (if he is, in fact, able to come back) has created a bit of a quandry. Between Reynolds and Jackson, the Dbacks are stocked at corner infield, but his $4.5ish million/year salary makes it difficult to relegate him to backup duty.

Mark Reynolds himself is a bit of an enigma. He’s a very streaky player who is currently 2nd only to Ryan Howard in strikeouts. He hasn’t even played a full season yet and he already has 24 HRs. His defense is above average (though he’s off to a rough start, racking up 7 errors already) and he’s becoming more of a threat on the base paths (4 steals already this year).
It’s a tough decision. I think Reynolds has more upside due to the fact that he’s younger than Tracy and is just starting in the Majors. But Tracy has shown that he could be outstanding. In 2005, Tracy’s VORP was 40 (!). It dropped quite a bit in 2006 to 16.3. Reynolds’ VORP was 19.2 in 3/4ths of a season and could have been a lot higher if not for his bad June and July when pitchers adjusted to his hitting tendencies.
This is another one of the many themes we will be returning back to throughout the year so feel free to send in any other potential Wally Pipps to us.